Michael "Ponytail Mike" William Fagin's Obituary
Michael "Ponytail Mike" Fagin peacefully left us on April 5th, 2026, in Fort Myers, Florida. Born in Cincinnati, Ohio, on February 19th, 1954, to William Fagin and Mary K. Fagin.
Mike was a beloved presence in the lives of all who knew him. Outgoing personality with a tremendous sense of humor, he made friends wherever he went.
He is survived by his loving wife, Clarice Rigsby Fagin; stepsons Ryan Cook and Steve Cook; brother Mark Fagin; sister-in-law Lisa Fagin; and uncle to their children, Jeremy Fagin; David Fagin and his wife Tanya, and their daughters Amber and Ariya, all of whom will miss him dearly.
In honor of Mike, remember to share a smile, lend a helping hand, and celebrate the small joys in life, just as he did every day. His spirit, love, and laughter will forever echo in the hearts of those who knew him.
What’s your fondest memory of Michael "Ponytail Mike"?
What’s a lesson you learned from Michael "Ponytail Mike"?
Share a story where Michael "Ponytail Mike"'s kindness touched your heart.
Describe a day with Michael "Ponytail Mike" you’ll never forget.
How did Michael "Ponytail Mike" make you smile?